Bag valve mask (BVM) ventilation is a foundational component of airway management in emergency medicine, yet it has distinct limitations compared to advanced airway techniques such as endotracheal intubation (ETI) and supraglottic airway devices. Several studies elucidate the reasons behind the suboptimal effectiveness of BVM ventilation when compared to advanced airway management in various emergency scenarios.
One fundamental difference is the effectiveness of ventilation achieved by BVM compared to advanced airway devices. BVM ventilation has been shown to be less reliable in providing sufficient oxygenation and ventilation, particularly in challenging conditions such as cardiac arrest or severe respiratory distress ("Association between prehospital airway management methods and neurologic", 2021; Kim et al., 2020).
When BVM is used, the efficacy can be compromised due to improper seal, difficulty in achieving adequate tidal volumes, or complications arising from gastric inflation, which increases the risk of aspiration and subsequent pneumonia (Choi et al., 2021; Mort, 2005). Furthermore, when BVM is employed, the risk of ineffective ventilation due to the complexity of managing the airway increases in cases where rapid intervention is critical (Hansen et al., 2016; Länkimäki et al., 2015).
In practice, studies indicate that advanced airway techniques, such as ETI and the use of laryngeal mask airways, provide more consistent ventilation rates than BVM, especially under continuous chest compressions, where maintaining adequate ventilation can be challenging (Dündar et al., 2021; Kurola et al., 2005). These advanced techniques allow for more definitive control of the airway, leading to reduced instances of hypoxia and improved gas exchange (Benger et al., 2018; Bosch et al., 2013). Notably, advanced devices such as the laryngeal mask airway have been shown to enhance the continuity of ventilation, thereby supporting better overall resuscitation outcomes (Ohashi-Fukuda et al., 2017).
Moreover, limitations in BVM effectiveness are particularly evident in specific patient demographics, such as critically ill patients or those with altered anatomy (e.g., obese patients), where physiological challenges exacerbate the difficulty of achieving effective bag-mask ventilation (Mort, 2005; Casey et al., 2018). Evidence indicates that advanced airway techniques improve survival rates and neurological outcomes in contexts such as out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (Benoit et al., 2015; Flavell & Boyle, 2010).
Additionally, the cognitive and psychomotor burden on rescue teams when using BVM cannot be underestimated, especially in high-pressure situations where clear decision-making is paramount (Lindström et al., 2010). The training and experience required for advanced airway management are significant, yet they rapidly become crucial in ensuring patient survival, especially as BVM effectiveness wanes following prolonged attempts to use it alone (Stuby et al., 2023; Lakshmanan et al., 2015). Therefore, in emergencies where time is critical, the precision and control of advanced airway techniques may provide essential advantages.
In conclusion, while BVM remains a vital tool in airway management, its limitations highlight the necessity for prompt transition to advanced airway techniques, which have been shown to offer superior effectiveness in terms of ventilation and patient outcomes during emergencies.
References:
- (2021). Association between prehospital airway management methods and neurologic outcome in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest with respiratory cause: a nationwide retrospective observational study. SV.
https://doi.org/10.22514/sv.2021.249
- Benger, J., Kirby, K., Black, S., Brett, S., Clout, M., Lazaroo, M., … & Rogers, C. (2018). Effect of a strategy of a supraglottic airway device vs tracheal intubation during out-of-hospital cardiac arrest on functional outcome. Jama, 320(8), 779.
https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2018.11597
- Benoit, J., Prince, D., & Wang, H. (2015). Mechanisms linking advanced airway management and cardiac arrest outcomes. Resuscitation, 93, 124-127.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resuscitation.2015.06.005
- Bosch, J., Nooij, J., Visser, M., Cannegieter, S., Terpstra, N., Heringhaus, C., … & Burggraaf, J. (2013). Prehospital use in emergency patients of a laryngeal mask airway by ambulance paramedics is a safe and effective alternative for endotracheal intubation. Emergency Medicine Journal, 31(9), 750-753.
https://doi.org/10.1136/emermed-2012-202283
- Casey, J., Janz, D., Russell, D., Vonderhaar, D., Joffe, A., Dischert, K., … & Semler, M. (2018). Manual ventilation to prevent hypoxaemia during endotracheal intubation of critically ill adults: protocol and statistical analysis plan for a multicentre randomised trial. BMJ Open, 8(8), e022139.
https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2018-022139
- Choi, Y., Kim, T., Hong, K., Song, K., & Shin, S. (2021). Association between prehospital airway management methods and neurologic outcome in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (ohca) with respiratory cause...
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-357226/v1
- Dündar, Z., Ayrancı, M., Koçak, S., & Girişgin, S. (2021). Bag-valve-mask versus laryngeal mask airway ventilation in cardiopulmonary resuscitation with continuous compressions: a simulation study. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, 36(2), 189-194.
https://doi.org/10.1017/s1049023x21000054
- Flavell, E. and Boyle, M. (2010). Which is more effective for ventilation in the prehospital setting during cardiopulmonary resuscitation, the laryngeal mask airway or the bag-valve-mask? - a review of the literature. Australasian Journal of Paramedicine, 8, 1-10.
https://doi.org/10.33151/ajp.8.3.94
- Hansen, M., Meckler, G., O’Brien, K., Engle, P., Dickinson, C., Dickinson, K., … & Guise, J. (2016). Pediatric airway management and prehospital patient safety. Pediatric Emergency Care, 32(9), 603-607.
https://doi.org/10.1097/pec.0000000000000742
- Kim, S., Lee, D., Moon, S., Ahn, J., Lee, W., Kim, J., … & Ryoo, H. (2020). Comparing the neurologic outcomes of patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest according to prehospital advanced airway management method and transport time interval. Clinical and Experimental Emergency Medicine, 7(1), 21-29.
https://doi.org/10.15441/ceem.19.002
- Kurola, J., Turunen, M., Laakso, J., Gorski, J., Paakkonen, H., & Silfvast, T. (2005). A comparison of the laryngeal tube and bag-valve mask ventilation by emergency medical technicians: a feasibility study in anesthetized patients. Anesthesia & Analgesia, 101(5), 1477-1481.
https://doi.org/10.1213/01.ane.0000182330.54814.70
- Lakshmanan, A., Szatkowski, L., Zinna, S., Clarkson, M., McClaughry, R., Soo, S., … & Sharkey, D. (2015). G109 restricting visitors to the nicu significantly reduces nosocomial viral respiratory tract infections in babies. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 100(Suppl 3), A47.1-A47.
https://doi.org/10.1136/archdischild-2015-308599.108
- Lindström, V., Svensén, C., Meissl, P., Turesson, B., & Castrén, M. (2010). End-tidal carbon dioxide monitoring during bag-valve ventilation: the use of a new portable device. Scandinavian Journal of Trauma Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine, 18(1), 49.
https://doi.org/10.1186/1757-7241-18-49
- Länkimäki, S., Alahuhta, S., Silfvast, T., & Kurola, J. (2015). Feasibility of lma supreme for airway management in unconscious patients by als paramedics. Scandinavian Journal of Trauma Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine, 23(1).
https://doi.org/10.1186/s13049-015-0105-3
- Mort, T. (2005). Preoxygenation in critically ill patients requiring emergency tracheal intubation*. Critical Care Medicine, 33(11), 2672-2675.
https://doi.org/10.1097/01.ccm.0000187131.67594.9e
- Ohashi-Fukuda, N., Fukuda, T., & Yahagi, N. (2017). Effect of pre-hospital advanced airway management for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest caused by respiratory disease: a propensity score–matched study. Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, 45(3), 375-383.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0310057x1704500314
- Stuby, L., Mühlemann, E., Jampen, L., Thurre, D., Siebert, J., & Suppan, L. (2023). Effect of intermediate airway management on ventilation parameters in simulated pediatric out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: protocol for a multicenter, randomized, crossover trial. Children, 10(1), 148.
https://doi.org/10.3390/children10010148